Protein Pudding Pie

Protein! I’m all about increasing it where I can. Lately I have been obsessed with my protein powders, shakes, protein fluff, and casein. It really is like a dessert to me rather than a supplement. Plus since I mix it with unsweetened almond milk, it’s good for you while keeping the calories low.

I thought to myself, what else can I do with this stuff? Then I thought back to the pudding pies my mom used to make me all the time. I literally could devour a whole pie by myself. She would make them with jell-o puddings, lactose free milk (sensitive tummy), cool whip, a graham cracker crust, and lots of jimmies (yum).

Well I made my own version of this using my protein powders (whey and casein). It is really simple to make, and you don’t need that many ingredients!

For this recipe you will need:

  • 2 cups of old fashioned oatsย 
  • 3.9 ounces of natural unsweetened apple sauce (about 1/2 cup)
  • 3 scoops of vanilla casein powder
  • 1 scoop of vanilla whey powder
  • 1/2 cup +1 Tablespoon of unsweetened vanilla almond milk
  • 1 cup of fat free evaporated milk (makes it creamy)
  • 1/2 Tablespoon of stevia in the raw
  • 5 drops of almond extract (if you don’t have this you can substitute with vanilla)
  • 1/4 cup of shredded raw organic coconut

(Makes 6-8 slices)

Preheat your oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit

Start by making the crust. This is so simple! All you do is add the oats and applesauce to a food processor. I pulse the oats alone first so they grind nicely before blending with the applesauce.

Pulsed Oats
Pulsed Oats
Pie crust! The applesauce works great to bind it together without the fat from butter
Pie crust! The applesauce works great to bind it together without the fat from butter

Spray a pie tin with extra virgin olive oil spray and evenly press the pie dough into the pan. Press up on the sides to create a nice crust!

Pressing the crust
Pressing the crust

Place in the oven for 25 minutes or until the top edges begin to brown

Pre bake pie
Pre bake pie

While this is cooking, prep the filling. To a large mixing bowl add three scoops of casein powder and 1 scoop of whey. The casein powder is what makes this pudding like, so really this should not be substituted. If you don’t have whey, you don’t need to add it, I just wanted an extra protein boost! Add the evaporated milk and almond milk and mix

The pie powders!
The pie powders!

Oh and don’t forget to mix in the stevia and almond extract!

I only added 5 SMALL drops of almond extract. It can be quite strong, but it gives it that "cake" taste
I only added 5 SMALL drops of almond extract. It can be quite strong, but it gives it that “cake” taste

When the pie crust is done, let it cool completely on the counter.

I love the edges of the pie crust
I love the edges of the pie crust

In the meantime, roast the shredded coconut on a baking sheet. I actually roasted 1/2 cup but it was too much. I ended up using 1/4 cup only. It only takes about 5 minutes! Keep an eye on this, it will burn easily.

I like these!
I like this kind!
It's like snow :)
It’s like snow ๐Ÿ™‚
Nice and golden brown
Toasted Coconut. Nice and golden brown

Now that your pie crust has cooled, add the filling!

Protein in a pie!
Protein in a pie!

Top with the toasted coconut

Beautiful Pie
Beautiful Pie

Pop in the fridge for at least 1 hour to let the casein set a bit more. The longer you keep it in the fridge, the better, but I simply couldn’t wait longer than an hour!

Protein Pudding Pie. A protein treat!
Protein Pudding Pie. A protein treat!

Yummy crust

After cutting the pie...
After cutting the pie…

Nutritional info per slice: (6 slices in one pie). 256.4 calories, 5.2 grams of fat, 31 grams of carbs, 24 grams of protein, 3.4 grams of sugar.ย 

I like big slices. While it’s more calories, it’s MORE protein! These are all good calories folks ๐Ÿ™‚ If you want to cut down on fat and calories a smidge you can cut out the toasted coconut, but it’s so yum! Live a little ๐Ÿ˜‰

If you want to compare this to an average vanilla mousse pie, the same serving would cost you around 525 calories, 27.2 grams of fat, 61.6 carbs, 16 grams of sugar and only 9 grams of protein versus my 24! I win again!

Perfect Piece of Pie!
Perfect Piece of Pie! BIG SLICE!

Happy eating…

XOXO WIth a Cherry On Top,


You Might Also Like


  1. Sarah C

    Omg!! I just said to my husband last night that bybhaving these protein shakes I make prettt much on a daily basis, I haven’t had any cravings for sweets! They’re like a treat for me too

    1. Katie

      They really are! I’ve been having protein fluff every single night, but now the pie! I’m obsessed

  2. kseniya

    What can I use instead of casein powder?

Leave a Reply