Valentine’s French Toast

I haven’t had french toast in a very long time. For some reason I always think of vacations! It’s one of those dishes you order when you are at your hotel at the sit down breakfast. I can remember going on a cruise to the Bahamas in 2009 and having the french toast in the dining room. You know it was good if I still remember it!

This french toast is healthier and is soaked overnight to create a wonderful moist dish. It’s baked in a casserole dish rather than a skillet, and still turns out amazing!

Perfect for a night you are having “breakfast for dinner”, a brunch, or an early rainy day.

Plus, it turns out absolutely adorable with the cookie cutters. Spreading the love through food!

For this recipe you will need:

-14 slices of bread. I used half 100% whole wheat, half ezekiel bread
-1 cup of unsweetened vanilla almond milk
-1/2 cup of egg whites
-2 teaspoons of cinnamon
-1 teaspoon of vanilla extract
-1 large scoop of vanilla protein powder
-1/2 teaspoon of salt
-2 Tablespoons of Splenda brown sugar
-1/4 cup of PB2 mixed with water
-sugar free syrup for topping
-heart cookie cutter

Start by mixing together your milk batter. Add the almond milk, egg whites, cinnamon, vanilla, protein powder, and salt.

The protein powder doesn't need to be completely smooth, it'll melt in the oven!
The protein powder doesn’t need to be completely smooth, it’ll melt in the oven!

Next prepare your slices of bread. Using a cookie cutter, make little heart shapes (I saved the edges of the ezekiel for a later use). Double up the slices when cutting.

Cookie cutter! 99 cents at Michaels
Cookie cutter! 99 cents at Michaels
Bread heart. Doubled up
Bread heart. Doubled up

I used half ezekiel and half 100% whole wheat because I wanted to see what would taste better. The ezekiel was MUCH better because it is a more dense bread. It soaked up the milk batter a lot better and still had a crunch versus the whole wheat which was a little soggier. I definitely recommend using all ezekiel!

Sprinkle the Splenda brown sugar blend in the bottom of a casserole dish

Sprinkled goodness
Sprinkled goodness- okay clearly this is more than 2 Tablespoons… whoops!

Place the bread on top of the brown sugar (still doubled up)

Hearts in a casserole dish
Hearts in a casserole dish

Pour the milk batter on top of the dish

Remember the protein clumps will melt. Sometimes this brand does this to me!
Remember the protein clumps will melt. Sometimes this brand does this to me!

Cover with saran wrap and place in the fridge overnight

Overnight or a few hours!
Overnight or a few hours!

Prepare the topping. I bought these heart molds the other day at Wegmans. It’s actually an ice cube tray, but I placed PB 2 in them!

Fill and Freeze overnight
Fill and Freeze overnight

They pop out so easily and look at this lovely heart 🙂

Perfect Portion
Perfect Portion

The next morning/night preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Cook for 30 minutes

Ezekiel was amazing. And the batter soaked up in the bread!
Ezekiel was amazing. And the batter soaked up in the bread!

Serve up slices with sugar free maple syrup and top with PB2 hearts!

Valentines French Toast
Valentine’s French Toast

My entire “breakfast for dinner” meal

French Toast, turkey bacon, eggs, and kiwi!
French Toast, turkey bacon, eggs, and kiwi!

Make this french toast! It won’t disappoint, plus a protein boost from the powder! 🙂

Happy eating…

XOXO With a Cherry On Top,

-Minnie

You Might Also Like

3 Comments

  1. Brittany

    Hi Minnie! I am looking forward to changing into a healthy lifestyle and I have been doing some research and came across your blog which has by far been my favorite!!! I look forward to starting!

    🙂 Love your blog!!

    1. Katie

      Aw thank you Brittany! Welcome to my blog 😀

Leave a Reply